Artemisia Gentileschi, Sofonisba Anguissola and Marie Louise Elisabeth Vigee-Lebrun are self portraits contain important clues as to how each of these artists was perceived and how they saw the world. Compare and contrast these three paintings and come up with some conclusions as to how each artist chose to portray themselves. What do these portrayals tell us about the role of the artist in the Renaissance, Baroque and Rococo periods?
![]() Marie Louise Elisabeth Vigee-Lebrun with her daughter Julie - 1789 121 x 90 cm, The Louvre, Paris
|
Form: Both these portraits are done in a Rococo fashion.
The brushwork is light almost feathery and often the colors that are used
tend to run towards pastel in terms of their hue. The compositions
are fairly stable and symmetrical although the tenebrism tends to create
an almost vignette type of effect.
In the self portrait the artist has chosen a neoclassical looking garment and the texture of the background is undefined. In the portrait of Marie Antoinette, the queen is dressed in fairly expensive clothing however the clothing is not terribly ornate or ostentatious. Iconography: In both images, the artist has chosen to portray the female as a "good mother" in the manner that Rousseau advocated. In Rousseau's point of view the role of individuals was predetermined by their innate nature and that in order for an individual to fit into society as a whole one must live in accordance with this nature. In the case of females, this role was to have children and be good mothers. Both of these images subscribe to this point of view because these images were meant to be almost advertisements or a form of propaganda that would present a persona to the world. Context: By 1789, accusations of impropriety and adultery had destroyed her public reputation. This self portrait was an attempt to portray herself as a moral and upright Frenchwoman. The same was true for Marie Antoinette. In this painting Marie Antoinette is being depicted in modest clothing to defend against accusations of excessive spending and she is also portrayed as the good mother who had also lost a son. On the right is her brother, Louis, Le Dauphin gesturing toward the empty crib which indicates her loss. The last portrait of thirty that Vigee Le Brun painted of the doomed queen. The picture shows Marie Therese Charlotte de France, Madame Royale, and her brother, Louis, Le Dauphin. Louis died of natural causes early in the year that the revolution began. The next younger child, also called Louis then became the second Dauphin. After his father had been guillotined he became known as Louis XVII . This Louis may have been murdered, or may have died of other causes while imprisoned in the temple, but he may also have survuved after having been exchanged for another sickly child. This painting still hangs at Versailles.Go here for a great bio on Marie Antoinette http://www.geocities.com/BourbonStreet/Delta/6569/ |
|
![]() Angelica Kauffman, Cornelia Pointing to Her Children as Her Treasures, 1785. oil on canvas, 40"x50" Virginia Museum of Fine Arts, Richmond, Virginia Neoclassic, worked in England born in Switzerland
|
Form: This painting is Neoclassic in style because it
incorporates classical clothing and architecture and is organized in a
classical manner. The composition is also arranged in a similar manner
to Grueze's
and Poussin's paintings. Like its Baroque
French counterparts, the image is constructed so that most of the figures
are placed in the foreground and even though there is the creation of deep
space, the background is not as important as the figures.
The picture plane is arranged in a sculptural frieze like band that takes its cue from antique sculptural friezes such as those found on the Ara Pacis and the Parthenon. Like its classical counterparts, the image is constructed so that most of the figures are placed in the foreground and even though there is the creation of deep space, the background is not as important as the figures. Stokstad goes into the specific story of the Cornelia and the Gracchii and so this next section will be dedicated to some other aspects of the image. The use of classical imagery, such as the togas and columns, and a story that deals specifically with self sacrifice for the generations of the future. The classical clothing and arches referred to a tradition that was considered more dignified than the light classical themes expressed in paintings like Watteau's. The lighting and the frieze like placement of the figures are equally a part of the iconography of this image because these formal elements directly refer to those classical traditions. Compare Watteau's style of painting and see how the formal qualities of each actually are part of the iconography. The individuals being represented are also all physically beautiful and this refers to the classical concept of kalos (Greek for beautiful and moral.) In a twist on the classical vocabulary found in the Stele of Hegeso, Kauffman corrects the iconography and updates it. The prescribed role of woman is specifically expressed in this image as that of a mother rather than a selfish woman who cares only for jewels. This philosophy is very much in keeping with Rousseau's ideas concerning that of the "happy mother" and in her depiction of Cornelia she is almost changing the meaning of the image found on the stele. Context: According to WebGalleries, This fine painting combines the 18th century attributes of loving and attentive mother with Roman classicizing elements. Kauffmann presents us with the narrative subject of "exemplum virtutis" or example of virtue. Here a wealthy women sits showing off her jewels. When she asks Cornelia to present her jewels, Cornelia raises her hand to bring forth her sons, Tiberus and Gaius, saying "These are my jewels". The subjects are clothed in roman dress and set against a roman background. An interesting comparison can be made to Jacques Louis David's "Oath of the Horatii". |
neo.clas.sic or neo.clas.si.cal adj (1877): of, relating to, or constituting a revival or adaptation of the classical esp. in literature, music, art, or architecture -- neo.clas.si.cism n -- neo.clas.si.cist n or adjvi.gnette n [F, fr. MF vignete, fr. dim. of vigne vine--more at vine] (1751) 2 a: a picture (as an engraving or photograph) that shades off gradually into the surrounding paper b: the pictorial part of a postage stamp design as distinguished from the frame and lettering 3 a: a short descriptive literary sketch b: a brief incident or scene (as in a play or movie) -- vi.gnett.ist n ²vignette vt vi.gnett.ed ; vi.gnett.ing (1853) 1: to finish (as a photograph) in the manner of a vignette 2: to describe briefly -- vi.gnett.er n